Do not read this if you haven't watched
the entire thing. Or really I'd be doing you a favour if you did, but
I've noticed that people prefer to find stuff out on their own rather
than have me shove it down their throats.
I wanted to like this show. I really
wanted to. Even in spite of those continuous comparisons to Twin
Peaks (don't push your luck, know what I'm sayin'). I liked that they
cast Bill Skarsgård, as a Scandinavian it's always lovely when one
of our own lands a big part away from home.
I watched every single episode, and
held my tongue through it all, but after the last episode I thought I
was going to explode.
I won't talk about the terrible
dialogue or Famkes ridiculous character, mainly because I feel it's
been mocked to death already.
But have serious issues with everything
that leaves you with tons of loose ends. Sure, it's based on a book,
and as I haven't read that I don't know how it's done there. But one
of the main issues for me was how they end one episode on a dramatic
note and then the next episode doesn't start up exactly where the
previous left off. That's important enough when you get a week
between each episode, but one might think that when it comes to a
Netflix-series where people can (and most of the time will) watch
everything at once it might be an idea to put the episodes together
better.
It's pretty clear that (author) have a
plan to write the next big thing in teen-supernatral-literature (like
we didn't have enough already), and therefore stuffs tons of stuff in
the first book to be resolved later in the book series. Fine. My
problem is that the Netflix series does the same, even though it's
not yet been resolved if it will get a second season or not.
It's an art to introduce storylines
that doesn't really have anything to do with the main plot, but the
problem in Hemlock Grove is that they make the subplot way more
interesting than the main plot.
They also seemed to think that
mysterious is the same as not having a clue what it going on, and
keep giving us drips and drops of interesting information here and
there, only to follow up with boring teen-drama to draw our attention
away from the fact that Destiny or anyone else for that matter
probably don't have a clue.
This is basically just a series about a
murderous werewolf (or vargulf if you will, nothing says badass
mystery like random European words) with a Twilight-love-triangle
thrown in.
Sure, maybe it was a fun twist that a
shy teen girl turned into a viscious killer, but not entirely
original is it. Another thing that's gotten oodles of praise is that
werewolf transformation.
Why, is another question. Are we really
so starved for variation in this field that anything slightly out of
the ordinary is worth being called «impressive», «epic» and «mind
blowing» (real quotes from ass-licking tweeters, this).
Sure, I'm all for fresh ideas. But they
better be thought through before they're put on screen.
The only part I liked was that I
assumed the wolf ate all the human bits to recycle them (much like
spiders do with their webs), but this is only good if it works both
ways, and we never got to see a wolf to human-transition. Oh wait, we
did. When Christina died, she magically changed back to human with no
gore at all. Nothing «mind blowing» about this.
Thing is, I forgot about the main
plotline at once. Whenever they talked about the vargulf or the
murdered girls all I could think was 'yeah yeah, get to the fun
stuff!'
The fun stuff being the one part of
this show that was slightly different from every other teen show out
there: A dashingly handsome Frankenstein and his teenage monster.
Shelley was the only character I cared
about and the connection between her and dr. Pryce gave infinitely
much more than anything Roman/Letha/Peter got up to.
(It must be said that I do have a soft
spot for anything that even vaguely recembles a mad doctor/scientist,
and here he even had a massive facility with creepy experiments, and
terrifying sights that drive people mad, so how could a girl like me
possibly resist?)
To me this was way more exciting, and
it didn't help that it was clearly linked to several characters in
the story, as the only characters the series chose to focus on was
the Twilight-kids.
Either the project Ouroboros-plot
should have been the main one, or the should just have saved it for
season two. The worst part is that they'd probably have time to put
everything in there, as some episodes were super boring and seemed to
spend way too much time on the Peter/Roman/Letha-love triangle. The
last episode left a lot to be desired, even though it was one of the
few episodes to include all the characters (which they should have
done all the way).
The whole thing almost comes down to 13
hours. That's a lot of time.
They didn't save on the
ouroboros-symbolism either, it's in the logo, on Lethas hand, on
Romans shirt and mentioned a million times. And sure, it means
rebirth and yada yada yada, but that's not good enough. When they
named Pryce's project after the thing, you naturally expect that to
be the reason for the heavy symbolism. Which of course it wasn't. I
suspect they wanted us all just to accept Peters werewolfism or
Romans transformation in the last episode to be good enough. Hell no.
This was another point that
disappointed me. I closed my ears from the first time they mentioned
upir. I hoped and hoped that they wouldn't go the whole Twilight-way,
but creativity must have died early, as this thing seemed to follow a
recipe from scene one, only with some gore and sex thrown in to throw
us off the scent. Didn't work, did it.
I really wanted to believe Bill scored
the a big part for being an exciting actor, but sure does feel like
he only got it because his brother is already famous for being the
hottest vampire on tv. So sad.
All in all this was a poorly executed
idea, with good actors thrown it to give the illusion of quality.
I'm sure I could find several things in
every single episode that is poorly written, badly thought through or
just plain bad, but the thought of watching this thing again is less
tempting than giving birth to a wolf through my face.
But someone please tell me, WTF is up
with «I have seen the dragon»?!
Hi Beaver,
SvarSlettCongratulation, you did what I didn't manage to do: watch every episode of Hemlock Grove. You pretty much sums up the reasons why I couldn't stand the show. I also liked Shelley and found her character the most interesting.
The show reminded me somewhat of American Horror Story because it appeared just as aimless and confused.
That transformation isn't new. Check out the film The Company of Wolves from 1984. There are several types of transformations in that film and the one you see in Hemlock Grove is one of them.
It bugged me that we were just supposed to accept Shelley as a modern Frankensteins monster when she really just looked like an alien, and I wish they'd given us some explanation as to why she glowed.
SlettAnd I accidentally stumbled across In The Company of Wolves the other day, how I love that the only thing that has been called original with HG is a rip-off as well <3